Comparative Analysis of Cost and Time Between Flexible and Rigid Pavement on the Siwalanpanji Kemiri

Tri Perwira Hariyanto; Wateno  Oetomo; Risma  Marleno

doi:10.59888/ajosh.v3i10.584

Authors

Tri Perwira Hariyanto Universitas 17 Agustus 1945 Surabaya, Indonesia
Wateno Oetomo Universitas 17 Agustus 1945 Surabaya, Indonesia
Risma Marleno Universitas 17 Agustus 1945 Surabaya, Indonesia

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.59888/ajosh.v3i10.584

Keywords:

Rigid pavement, flexible pavement, road design, cost analysis, MDPJ 2024, Sidoarjo infrastructure

Abstract

This research presents a comparative analysis of the cost and construction time between flexible and rigid pavement structures on the Siwalanpanji-Kemiri road section in Sidoarjo Regency, East Java, Indonesia. The area is undergoing a functional shift from rural to industrial, necessitating durable infrastructure to accommodate increasing heavy vehicle traffic. Using the 2024 Indonesian Pavement Design Manual (MDPJ), the research evaluates the technical and economic viability of both pavement types over 20-year and 40-year service lives. Key parameters include Average Daily Traffic (ADT) projections, Cumulative Equivalent Single Axle Load (CESAL), and subgrade strength derived from Dynamic Cone Penetrometer (DCP) tests. These inputs inform pavement thickness designs and cost estimates based on local unit prices (HSPK). Findings reveal that flexible pavement offers faster construction (9 days vs. 39–49 days for rigid) but incurs 38% higher long-term costs due to frequent maintenance. Rigid pavement, despite longer initial construction time, proves more economical over 40 years, with lower maintenance needs and superior durability under heavy loads. Cost analysis shows rigid pavement saves up to IDR 3.5 billion compared to flexible alternatives over four decades. The study also highlights the sustainability benefits of reusing existing materials, aligning with environmental goals. These results provide actionable insights for the Sidoarjo Public Works Agency, emphasizing rigid pavement as the optimal choice for industrializing corridors. The research underscores the importance of life-cycle cost analysis and context-specific design in infrastructure planning, offering a model for similar regions facing rapid urbanization and traffic growth.

References

Assa, T. F., Palenewen, S. C. N., & Waani, J. E. (2022). Perbandingan analisa tebal perkerasan lentur (flexible pavement) dan perkerasan kaku (rigid pavement) terhadap rencana anggaran biaya. Tekno, 20(82).

Firmansyah, R., Amsori, M. D. A. S., & Dony, W. (2022). Perencanaan rigid pavement pada rekontruksi kapasitas struktur di ruas Jalan Bensol Kota Jambi. Jurnal Talenta Sipil, 5(1), 26–34.

Lelepadang, S., Nuhun, R., Nasrul, N., & Ahmad, S. N. (2020). Analisis perbandingan biaya konstruksi perkerasan kaku (rigid pavement) dan perkerasan lentur (flexible pavement) (Studi kasus: Jalan Prof. M. Yamin, Kelurahan Puuwatu, Kota Kendari). Stabilita: Jurnal Ilmiah Teknik Sipil, 8(3). https://doi.org/10.55679/jts.v8i3.16192

Maharani, A., & Wasono, S. B. (2018). Perbandingan perkerasan kaku dan perkerasan lentur (Studi kasus ruas Jalan Raya Pantai Prigi – Popoh Kab. Tulungagung). Ge-STRAM: Jurnal Perencanaan dan Rekayasa Sipil, 1(2). https://doi.org/10.25139/jprs.v1i2.1202

Mahardika, V., Mudiyono, R., & Soedarsono, S. (2021). Perbandingan konstruksi dan biaya untuk struktur perkerasan lentur, kaku dan paving blok pada Jalan Pantai Utara Flores. Ge-STRAM: Jurnal Perencanaan dan Rekayasa Sipil, 4(1). https://doi.org/10.25139/jprs.v4i1.3117

Prasetya, E. J., Marleno, R., & Tjendani, H. T. (2023). Analisis biaya investasi perkerasan lentur dan perkerasan kaku (Studi kasus pada ruas Jalan Akses Rusun PPI_TPI Romokalisari Surabaya). Jurnal Spesialis Teknik Sipil (JSpTS), 3(1). https://doi.org/10.30996/jspts.v3i1.7092

Rozanova, I., & Syarifudin, A. (2022). Analisis value engineering pada proyek jalan dan jembatan menurut persepsi pelaku jasa konstruksi. Jurnal Deformasi, 7(1). https://doi.org/10.31851/deformasi.v7i1.7656

Tiara, M., Rochmanto, D., & Saputro, Y. A. (2022). Perencanaan tebal perkerasan kaku ruas Jalan Raya Jepara Bangsri pada KM 11 sampai KM 12 menggunakan Pedoman Bina Marga 2017. Jurnal Civil Engineering Study, 2.

Woro Sukarno, E. (2022). Studi kasus perbandingan efisiensi biaya antara pekerjaan jalan perkerasan kaku (rigid pavement) dengan perkerasan lentur (flexible pavement) di Kabupaten Ngawi. Jurnal Impresi Indonesia, 1(10). https://doi.org/10.58344/jii.v1i10.525

Salim, A. K., Darmawan, M. A., & Wibowo, H. (2020). Analisa perbandingan biaya perkerasan kaku dan perkerasan lentur pada proyek Jalan Middle Ring Road Kota Makassar. Jurnal Teknik Sipil MACCA, 5(1), 41–47.

Aditiya, R. E., & Siswoyo, S. (2020). Perencanaan rigid pavement dan rencana anggaran biaya di Jalan Babat – Batas Jombang Kabupaten Lamongan. Axial: Jurnal Rekayasa dan Manajemen Konstruksi, 8(2), 79–90.

American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials. (1993). AASHTO guide for design of pavement structures. AASHTO.

Austroad. (1987). Pavement design: A guide to the structural design of road pavements. Austroad Incorporated.

Badan Pusat Statistik Kabupaten Sidoarjo. (2023). Kabupaten Sidoarjo dalam angka 2023. BPS Kabupaten Sidoarjo. https://sidoarjokab.bps.go.id/publication/2023/02/28/ed054b1e274aa8e0eb0e406a/kabupaten-sidoarjo-dalam-angka-2023.html

Departemen Pemukiman dan Prasarana Wilayah. (2002). Perencanaan tebal perkerasan lentur Pd T-01-2002-B. Badan Pusat Penelitian dan Pengembangan Pemukiman dan Prasarana Wilayah.

Fajar, C., & Oetomo, W. (2023). Analisis rencana anggaran biaya dan durasi pekerjaan perkerasan jalan pada proyek peningkatan jalan Weekapoda–Dikira Kabupaten Sumba Barat Daya. Jurnal Sains Riset, 13(2), 505–515. https://doi.org/10.47647/jsr.v10i12

Hardiyatmo, H. C. (2015). Perancangan perkerasan jalan dan penyelidikan tanah. Gadjah Mada University Press.

Kurniawan, H., & Djunaidi, Mr. (2020). Studi perbandingan konstruksi perkerasan lentur (flexible pavement) dan perkerasan kaku (rigid pavement) ditinjau dari biaya studi kasus: Peningkatan kualitas Jalan Sungai Pinang–Pantai Mempanak Kabupaten Lingga. SIGMA TEKNIKA, 3(1). https://doi.org/10.33373/sigma.v3i1.2452

Saefulloh, M. I. (2022). Analisis tebal perkerasan lentur Jalan Tawang–Ngalang segmen IV dan Jalan Klangon–Tempel dengan metode MDPJ 2017 [Skripsi Sarjana, Universitas Gadjah Mada].

Nasution, A. M. (2019). Perbandingan tebal perkerasan terhadap kelas jalan [Tesis, Universitas Indonesia].